What are E. coli and Total Coliforms?

Microbiological results are the ones that make people sit up. An E. coli detection can lead to boil water advice, while a total coliform result often causes more concern than it deserves. Understanding what each test is actually detecting makes the difference clear.

What are these tests actually measuring?
Neither test looks for the organisms that make people sick. There are hundreds of waterborne pathogens, including bacteria, viruses and protozoa, and testing for each one routinely isn't practical. Instead, we test for indicator bacteria: organisms that are easy to grow in the lab and tell us something about where the water has been.
Total coliforms
"Coliform" isn't a single species. It's a group of bacteria defined by what they do in the lab: rod-shaped bacteria that can ferment lactose (milk sugar) using an enzyme called β-galactosidase.
Some coliforms live in the gut of warm-blooded animals, but many live quite happily in soil, on plants and in biofilms inside pipes and tanks. So a total coliform result tells you that bacteria of this general type are present. It doesn't tell you they came from faeces.
E. coli
Escherichia coli is one specific species within the coliform group. It lives in the intestines of humans and warm-blooded animals in very large numbers, and it doesn't usually survive long or multiply in the environment. Most strains also produce a second enzyme, β-glucuronidase, which other coliforms generally don't.
That combination makes E. coli the most specific indicator of recent faecal contamination we have. If E. coli is in the water, faecal material got in somewhere, and pathogens may have come with it.
How are they measured?
Labs commonly use one of two approaches, and both make use of the enzymes described above.
Enzyme substrate tests. The sample is mixed with a growth medium containing compounds that change colour or fluoresce when they're broken down by coliform or E. coli enzymes. The sample is then split into several portions, and the number of positive portions is used to calculate a most probable number (MPN). The Aquagenx Compartment Bag Test (CBT) is one example: a 100 mL sample is divided into five compartments of different volumes, compartments containing E. coli turn blue, and the pattern of positive compartments is read from a table to give the MPN. Some versions also detect total coliforms, which fluoresce under UV light. Signals differ between products, so always read results using the instructions for the test being used.
Membrane filtration. The sample is passed through a fine filter, which is then placed on a growth medium, often one that colours coliform and E. coli colonies differently. After incubation the colonies are counted, giving colony forming units (cfu).
Whichever method is used, results are reported per 100 mL. Depending on the lab and method, you may see units such as cfu/100 mL, MPN/100 mL or organisms/100 mL. For reading results they mean the same thing: how many were detected in 100 mL of water. Results are usually available within one to two days of the sample reaching the lab.
A result of "<1" means nothing was detected in the 100 mL tested.
Getting the sample right matters. Samples are collected in sterile bottles containing sodium thiosulfate to neutralise chlorine, kept cool and delivered quickly. Many unexpected coliform results trace back to sampling.
As a guide
Result | What it suggests |
E. coli <1, coliforms <1 | Nothing detected. The expected result for treated drinking water. |
E. coli <1, coliforms detected | Not evidence of faecal contamination. Points to regrowth, low disinfectant, an integrity issue or sampling. |
E. coli detected | Evidence of faecal contamination. Needs immediate action. |
How are they used in the water industry?
Verifying treated water
Routine E. coli sampling across a supply checks that treatment and disinfection are doing their job. Because results take about a day, this is verification after the fact. The real-time protection comes from managing barriers such as filtration and chlorine residual, and a clear E. coli record is the evidence that they're working.
Understanding source water
E. coli counts in raw water show how much faecal contamination is coming from a catchment, whether from livestock, wildlife, septic systems or sewage. Under the health-based targets approach, source water E. coli data helps classify catchment risk and set how much treatment a supply needs.
Checking system integrity
Total coliforms are useful as a general hygiene check. They're commonly used after mains repairs, when commissioning new mains and tanks, and to investigate reservoirs or parts of the network with low chlorine. A coliform detection on its own isn't a faecal signal, but it's a reason to look more closely.
Responding to incidents
An E. coli detection in drinking water is treated as real until shown otherwise. Typical steps are notifying in line with the supplier's plan and regulator, checking chlorine residuals, resampling around the site, inspecting the sample tap, reviewing recent works and events, and working with the health regulator on whether public advice is needed.
Recycled water
E. coli is also a key verification parameter for recycled water, with limits set by the class of water and its intended use.
The limits of E. coli
E. coli is a good indicator for bacterial pathogens, but not for everything. Viruses and protozoa such as Cryptosporidium and Giardia are much more resistant to chlorine, so water can be free of E. coli and still carry them. That is why filtration performance, turbidity and C.t matter so much.
Where the guidelines fit
The Australian Drinking Water Guidelines state that E. coli should not be detected in any 100 mL sample of drinking water. There is no guideline value for total coliforms.
Key points
E. coli and coliforms are indicator bacteria, not the pathogens themselves.
Total coliforms include many environmental bacteria, so they are a general hygiene indicator.
E. coli lives in the gut of warm-blooded animals and indicates recent faecal contamination.
E. coli does not indicate viruses or protozoa, so treatment barriers still matter.
A detection can be stressful, particularly for smaller suppliers without a dedicated water quality team. Having a clear, practised response plan makes a big difference. If you'd like support reviewing your monitoring or incident procedures, the Viridis team is happy to help.
References
Australian Drinking Water Guidelines, Escherichia coli fact sheet. NHMRC, NRMMC (2011, updated).
Australian Drinking Water Guidelines, Total coliforms fact sheet. NHMRC, NRMMC (2011, updated).
What is Turbidity? Viridis Consultants.




Comments